We Analyzed 1,000+ U.S. Athletic Shirt Reviews—Here's What Matters Most to Gym-Goers

What do real people want from their workout shirts? We dug into the data so you don’t have to.

Methodology

To get a clear picture of what Americans truly value in their athletic shirts, we analyzed over 1,000 verified reviews from:

Our goal? Identify the most frequently mentioned praise points, complaints, and trends that brands—and shoppers—should know about.

Key Insights from U.S. Reviews

1. Fit & Feel Matter More Than Logos

Across the board, fit and comfort were king. Over 60% of reviewers—men and women alike—prioritized how well a shirt fits and moves with the body. Words like “flattering,” “not too clingy,” and “soft on skin” appeared consistently.

This is especially important in women’s athletic shirts, where many shoppers reported frustration with inconsistent sizing or overly tight sleeves. For men’s athletic shirts, a recurring theme was shoulder mobility and the desire for room in the chest while still tapering at the waist.

“It’s stretchy but doesn’t sag, and it holds up during intense lifting days. Super breathable too.” — Amazon Reviewer

2. Moisture-Wicking Isn’t Optional—It’s Expected

Nearly half of the positive reviews referenced sweat-control features. Whether it was for weightlifting, running, or hot yoga, Americans expect performance apparel to keep up. Moisture-wicking technology is now a baseline standard, not a bonus.

Brands like Under Armour HeatGear and Nike Dri-FIT were frequently praised for delivering comfort even during tough workouts.

“They're soft, very thin, and dry super quickly. You can't go wrong with these.” — Men’s Health Review

3. Durability Still Wins Loyalty

Fit and feel may drive the first purchase, but durability earns long-term trust. Athletes expect shirts to survive repeated washes and tough sessions without losing shape or performance.

Premium brands like Ten Thousand and Vuori stood out for lasting quality, while even affordable Amazon picks like icyzone impressed buyers with long-term wear.

“Ten Thousand’s shirts have held up well to even the most sweat-stain prone among us.” — Men’s Health

But Function Isn't Everything: The Rise of Purpose-Driven Performance Wear

Beyond the technical specs, one trend we noticed across Reddit and social media was a growing desire for apparel with meaning.

This shift reflects a deeper cultural moment—where people aren’t just dressing for performance, but for purpose. Whether it’s spreading awareness about mental health, honoring personal battles like sobriety or cancer recovery, or finding community in struggle, athletic apparel is becoming a form of self-expression and resilience.

At Riseabove Apparel, this mission is central. Our collections of motivational shirts, recovery shirts, and mental health shirts are inspired by the real stories of individuals rising above life’s challenges. From postpartum recovery to navigating anxiety or honoring a loved one’s cancer battle, every piece is designed with both comfort and conviction.

And unlike fast fashion, each product—whether it’s men’s athletic shirts, women’s athletic shirts, or shirts for a cause—is built to stand up to the workout and the message behind it.

Final Takeaways for Shoppers & Brands

If you're looking to build or buy a better athletic shirt in 2025, here’s what matters most to real U.S. consumers:

  • ✅ Get the fit right—especially across different body types

  • ✅ Prioritize sweat-wicking and odor-resistant materials

  • ✅ Build for durability: the gym doesn’t go easy, and neither should your shirt

  • ✅ Lean into meaning: performance and purpose aren’t mutually exclusive

Apparel that performs is great. Apparel that inspires? That’s even better.

Back to blog

Leave a comment